For over a decade, Benni McCarthy’s record of 31 goals for Bafana Bafana
has stood as an untouchable monument. Since his final appearance in 2012, a
procession of strikers has tried and fallen short in the chase to become
South Africa’s all-time leading scorer.
Bernard Parker came closest with 23 goals before his international career
waned. Percy Tau once seemed a likely heir, but his tally has stalled at 20,
and at 31, his window of opportunity is rapidly closing under coach Hugo
Broos.
Now, a new wave of attacking talent is breathing fresh life into the
pursuit, each with a credible path to challenge the legendary mark.
Lyle Foster: The Heir Apparent
At just 25 years old and already with 8 international goals, Foster is the
clear frontrunner. His platform in the English Premier League with Burnley
provides him with the pedigree and visibility to be the primary contender.
With time on his side, consistent fitness and form could see him rewrite the
history books.
Evidence Makgopa: The Trusted Protégé
Trusted by coach Hugo Broos, Makgopa is steadily building his case. While
his five goals may seem modest, his role as the team’s traditional No. 9
offers him the consistent playing time necessary to accumulate numbers. The
foundation is there; now he needs to sharpen his finishing to convert
opportunities into goals.
Oswin Appollis: The Dark Horse
The wildcard in the race, the 24-year-old Appollis brings flair,
versatility, and a growing confidence. Already on the scoresheet and now a
regular starter, his high ceiling and unpredictable style make him a player
capable of a surprise surge.
The verdict? Foster remains the most convincing candidate to finally topple
the record. Makgopa has the coach’s faith but needs the stats to match,
while Appollis is the exciting joker in the pack. For now, Benni McCarthy’s
record remains secure, but after 13 years of solitude, a serious challenge
is finally brewing.
